Choosing the Right Shopify Payments Gateways for Your Store

Introduction

Choosing the right payment gateway is one of the most significant technical decisions a Shopify merchant will make. The gateways you select dictate your transaction fees, your payout speeds, and, most importantly, your conversion rate at the final stage of the customer journey. While Shopify Payments is the standard for many, a global business often requires a mix of third-party providers to meet local buyer expectations and manage operational costs.

Managing multiple Shopify payments gateways effectively requires more than just turning them on in your admin settings. We built HidePay to give merchants the granular control needed to show the right payment options to the right customers at the right time — you can learn more about HidePay on the Shopify App Store. This guide explores how to evaluate different gateways and how to use conditional logic to optimize your checkout performance.

By the end of this article, you will understand the fee structures of major providers and how to structure your checkout to maximize profit while minimizing friction.

Understanding the Role of Shopify Payments Gateways

A payment gateway is the technology that captures and transfers payment data from the customer to the acquirer. In the Shopify ecosystem, gateways are divided into two main categories: Shopify’s own integrated solution and third-party providers.

The gateway serves as the digital equivalent of a physical point-of-sale terminal. It encrypts sensitive information, ensures the customer has sufficient funds, and communicates the authorization back to your store so you can fulfill the order. For merchants, the choice of gateway affects three core areas:

1. Transaction Fees: Every gateway charges a fee, usually a percentage of the sale plus a flat cent amount.
2. Customer Trust: Shoppers in different regions have specific "trust signals." A German shopper may look for Sofort, while a Dutch shopper expects iDEAL.
3. Checkout Flow: Some gateways keep the customer on your site, while others redirect them to an external page to complete the transaction.

Shopify Payments vs. Third-Party Providers

Shopify Payments is the native solution powered by Stripe. It is often the first choice because it eliminates "third-party transaction fees." If you use a third-party gateway like PayPal or Worldpay without having Shopify Payments active, Shopify charges an additional fee (ranging from 0.5% to 2% depending on your plan) on every transaction.

However, Shopify Payments is not available in every country. If your business is registered in a region where it is not supported, you must rely entirely on third-party gateways. Even if you do use Shopify Payments, you may still want to offer additional options like Amazon Pay or Klarna to give customers more flexibility.

Key Criteria for Evaluating a Payment Gateway

Do not choose a gateway based on brand recognition alone. Every provider has a different impact on your bottom line. Use the following criteria to evaluate potential partners.

Geographic Coverage and Currency Support

Confirm the gateway supports both the country where your business is registered and the countries where your customers live. A gateway might allow you to accept payments from 200 countries but only pay out to a bank account in the United Kingdom or the United States. Furthermore, look for "multi-currency" support. You want a gateway that allows customers to pay in their local currency to avoid cart abandonment caused by unexpected exchange rate fees.

Fee Structure and Hidden Costs

Gateways generally charge a "processing fee" per transaction. However, you must also look for:

• Monthly Subscription Fees: Some enterprise-grade gateways charge a flat monthly fee regardless of volume.
• Settlement Fees: Fees charged when moving money from the gateway to your bank account.
• Chargeback Fees: The amount you are charged when a customer disputes a transaction.
• Refund Fees: Some providers do not return the original processing fee when you issue a refund to a customer.

Integration Type

Shopify supports different integration methods. "Hosted" gateways redirect the customer away from your checkout page to the provider's site. "Self-hosted" or "API-based" gateways allow the customer to enter their details directly on your Shopify checkout page. Generally, keeping the customer on your site leads to higher conversion rates because it feels more professional and reduces the number of steps in the process.

Top Shopify Payments Gateways Analyzed

Most successful Shopify stores use a combination of 2–3 gateways to cover different customer preferences. Here is an analysis of the most common options.

Shopify Payments

As the default option, it offers the deepest integration. You can track your payouts and manage chargebacks directly within the Shopify admin. It supports "Shop Pay," which is one of the fastest accelerated checkout methods available. For stores in supported regions, this should almost always be your primary gateway to avoid extra Shopify transaction fees.

PayPal Express Checkout

PayPal is virtually mandatory for global e-commerce. Many shoppers feel more secure using PayPal because they do not have to share their credit card details with the merchant. While PayPal’s merchant fees can be higher than Shopify Payments, the increase in conversion often offsets the cost. One specific benefit is that PayPal has its own robust dispute resolution system, which some merchants find easier to navigate than bank-level chargebacks.

If you need to manage PayPal visibility specifically, HidePay includes a targeted guide for hiding the PayPal Express Checkout button in checkout to prevent it from appearing in unwanted contexts.

Stripe

While Stripe powers Shopify Payments, some merchants choose to use a standalone Stripe account if they have complex needs or operate in regions where Shopify Payments isn't live. Stripe is known for its developer-friendly tools and its ability to handle recurring subscriptions with high reliability. It is a solid choice for B2B merchants or stores with a subscription-based business model.

Klarna and Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)

BNPL services like Klarna, Afterpay, and Affirm have become essential for stores selling high-ticket items. These gateways allow customers to split their purchase into interest-free installments while you, the merchant, receive the full payment upfront (minus a fee). BNPL providers usually charge higher transaction fees (often 4% to 6%), but they significantly increase the Average Order Value (AOV).

Authorize.net

This is a veteran in the space and is often preferred by larger businesses that need high levels of customization and security. It offers excellent fraud detection tools and supports a wide variety of payment types, including eChecks.

Why Sorting and Hiding Gateways Matters

As you add more Shopify payments gateways to your store, your checkout can become cluttered. A long list of payment icons can overwhelm a customer, leading to "choice paralysis." Furthermore, not every gateway is profitable for every order.

The Problem with Too Many Options

If a customer sees ten different ways to pay, they may hesitate. You want to guide them toward the most efficient and trustworthy method for their specific situation. For example, if you are selling to a customer in the United States, showing them a European-specific gateway like Bancontact is unnecessary and adds visual noise.

Protecting Your Margins

Some payment methods are more expensive for the merchant. If a customer chooses a BNPL option for a small $10 purchase, the high percentage fee and flat per-transaction cost might eat up your entire profit margin. In this case, it makes sense to hide expensive gateways for low-value orders.

Managing Risk

Certain gateways are more prone to chargebacks or fraud in specific regions. If you notice a high rate of fraudulent orders from a specific country using a particular payment method, the most effective solution is to hide that gateway for customers in that geography.

If you want a deeper look at why HidePay was created and how it fits into checkout optimization strategy, read the Nextools introduction to HidePay on our blog.

Implementing Smart Payment Rules

The most effective way to manage your gateways is through conditional logic. Instead of a "one-size-fits-all" checkout, you can create a dynamic experience that adapts to the contents of the cart and the identity of the buyer.

Sorting for Conversion

The order in which gateways appear matters. Most customers will choose the first or second option they see. You should sort your gateways so that the most trusted, lowest-friction options (like Shopify Payments or Shop Pay) appear at the top. If you have a preferred gateway with lower fees, moving it to the first position can save your business thousands of dollars in processing costs over time.

For step-by-step instructions on sorting and renaming payment methods in HidePay, see the dedicated help guide that walks through drag-and-drop sorting and renaming.

Renaming for Clarity

Sometimes the default name of a gateway is confusing. You might want to rename "PayPal Express Checkout" to "Credit Card or PayPal" to reassure customers who don't have a PayPal account that they can still use their card. Customizing these labels helps localized stores feel more native to their target market.

Geographic and Product-Based Hiding

You can create rules that trigger based on the customer's shipping address or the products in their cart.

• By Country: Hide Cash on Delivery (COD) for every country except where you have a reliable local courier to handle collections.
• By Product Type: If you sell digital products, you may want to hide certain gateways that do not offer seller protection for non-physical goods.
• By Customer Tag: For your B2B customers, you might want to hide credit card options and only show "Bank Transfer" or "Invoice" to avoid high fees on large wholesale orders.

For concrete examples (cart attributes, collections, shipping method-based rules, and phone-number conditions), consult HidePay’s help documentation covering cart attributes, hiding by product collection, and more.

The Technical Edge: Shopify Functions

In the past, customizing the checkout required "Shopify Scripts," which were only available to Shopify Plus merchants and required complex Ruby coding. Today, the platform has moved to "Shopify Functions."

Our app is built on this native Shopify infrastructure. This is an important distinction because it means the logic happens directly within Shopify’s backend. There is no external script running on your checkout page that could slow down the loading speed or break when Shopify updates its theme engine. Using native functions ensures that your payment rules are reliable, fast, and secure.

If you want to explore how Shopify Functions are replacing Scripts more broadly, Nextools has a blog post explaining why Functions are the future and Scripts are the past.

Action Plan for Merchants

1. Audit your current fees: Look at your last month of transactions and calculate exactly what you paid in fees for each gateway.
2. Identify friction points: Check your "Abandoned Checkout" reports. Are customers dropping off at the payment stage?
3. Deploy logic: Use a tool to sort your most profitable gateways to the top and hide irrelevant ones.
4. Test one rule at a time: Change the order of your gateways and monitor the impact on your conversion rate for one week before making further changes.

When you’re ready to start deploying rules immediately, you can install HidePay to begin creating your first payment customizations.

Optimizing for Mobile and Express Checkouts

A significant portion of Shopify traffic comes from mobile devices. Mobile shoppers have a much lower tolerance for typing in credit card numbers. This is where "Express Checkout" buttons (like Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Shop Pay) are vital.

However, these buttons often appear at the very top of the checkout or even on the product page, sometimes bypassing your carefully crafted checkout flow. We allow you to block or hide these express buttons based on specific rules — refer to the help article about blocking Express Checkout with HidePay for the supported conditions and Shopify Plus limitations.

For merchants who also need to manage shipping visibility alongside payments, pairing HidePay with HideShip helps you control both payment and shipping options in tandem to reduce confusion and cart abandonment. Learn more about HideShip on the Shopify App Store.

Conclusion

Your choice of Shopify payments gateways is the foundation of your store's financial health. By balancing native options like Shopify Payments with trusted third-party providers, you create a checkout that serves a global audience. However, simply enabling these gateways is not enough. You must actively manage them to ensure they aren't hurting your margins or confusing your customers.

To maintain a high-performing checkout, remember these key takeaways:

• Prioritize Shopify Payments where available to minimize transaction fees.
• Use BNPL options strategically for higher-priced items to boost AOV.
• Clean up the UI by hiding irrelevant or high-fee gateways for specific cart conditions.
• Leverage native technology like Shopify Functions to ensure your checkout remains fast and stable.

If you are ready to take full control of your checkout experience, try HidePay on Shopify to start building a more profitable and professional payment flow today.

FAQ

Can I use multiple Shopify payments gateways at the same time?

Yes, Shopify allows you to enable Shopify Payments alongside several third-party providers like PayPal, Amazon Pay, and various Buy Now, Pay Later services. This allows you to offer your customers multiple ways to pay, which can help increase your conversion rate.

How do I avoid the extra transaction fees on Shopify?

To avoid the additional third-party transaction fees (which range from 0.5% to 2%), you must use Shopify Payments as your primary gateway. If you are in a supported region and use Shopify Payments, Shopify waives these extra fees even for orders processed through other methods like PayPal or manual payments.

Why would I want to hide a payment gateway from certain customers?

Merchants often hide gateways to reduce costs or manage risk. For example, you might hide Cash on Delivery for international orders to avoid shipping losses, or hide high-fee gateways like Klarna for low-value orders where the profit margin is thin. You can also hide specific gateways for high-risk countries to prevent chargebacks.

Is it possible to change the order of payment methods at checkout?

By default, Shopify determines the order of payment methods. However, by using an app built on Shopify Functions, you can reorder and sort these methods. This allows you to place your preferred, lower-fee options at the top of the list to encourage customers to use them.

---

• HidePay on the Shopify App Store — install HidePay to get started.
• How to sort and rename payment methods in HidePay (help doc).
• How to create a payment customization in HidePay (help doc).
• Hide the Express Checkout with HidePay (help doc).
• How to hide payment methods using cart attributes (help doc).
• HidePay introduction on the Nextools blog (educational post).
• Why Shopify Functions are the future (Nextools blog).
• HideShip on the Shopify App Store — cross-sell for shipping-rule needs.
• SupaEasy on the Shopify App Store — generate and migrate Shopify Functions codeless.